← ObservatoryThe RecordFR-AM-0005
PROG-AM
FR-AM-0005

Room-Temperature Superconductivity — Reproducibility Under Laboratory Conditions

A room-temperature superconductor can be produced under reproducible laboratory conditions.

CollapsedVS-04·since 2026-06-29
Verification Matrix
VS-01
Assertion
VS-02
Published
VS-03
Audit
VS-04
Replication
2024-01-15 — present
VS-05
Operation
State reached Current state Not yet reached
State Warrant
Current stateCollapsedVS-04
Why this state?Sourced from: SLAC/Stanford nickelate result via Physics World and ScienceDaily coverage (Feb 2025, reported through 2025–26); La-Sc-H 298K claim via Physics World coverage of an arXiv preprint (Nov 2025) — not independently replicated, and the arXiv preprint itself not directly read; PNAS roadmap referenced via secondary summary (March 2026), primary paper not directly read. Given this record's COLLAPSED/CLOSED status and the high public-interest sensitivity of room-temperature superconductivity claims, primary-source verification of the 298K claim in particular is recommended before this assessment is cited as authoritative.
Assessment summaryThe claim remains unsatisfied and the pressure state remains COLLAPSED. IN-006 documents that the field did not go quiet after the 2024 null result — a nickelate stabilisation at ambient pressure (Feb 2025), a new 298K high-pressure record (Nov 2025, unreplicated), and a March 2026 field-wide research roadmap all represent real activity — but none meets AT-001's reopening condition: zero resistance, Meissner effect, and specific-heat anomaly, confirmed independently, under the community's tightened standard. The November 2025 result is the closest superficial match to a 'room-temperature' headline since LK-99, and is explicitly logged here so that the record does not appear to have missed it; on examination it fails the same threshold IN-001 through IN-003 already established — high pressure, no independent confirmation, no full evidentiary set. This assessment exists to confirm the COLLAPSED state remains correct under current evidence, not to revise it. The record's status remains CLOSED.
State entered2024-01-15
Last reaffirmed2026-06-29
Stage provenanceRatified VS-04; stored historical code VS-05 preserved.
Record Lineage — Chronological
2024-01-15
Record opened — Collapsed
The claim has not been satisfied. No room-temperature superconductor has been reproduced under independent laboratory conditions to the community's current evidence standards. The two most prominent recent claims (Dias, LK-99) both failed replication — one through misconduct findings, one through rapid systematic null results from over forty independent groups. The confirmed high-pressure hydride results (INST-003) demonstrate that reproducible superconductivity approaching room temperature is achievable under extreme pressure, but not at room temperature or ambient pressure, and no material has met the community's evidence standard — zero resistance, Meissner effect, and specific heat anomaly, all independently confirmed — at conditions resembling laboratory practicality. The pressure state is COLLAPSED: the claim has been tested repeatedly, most recently and most rapidly in the LK-99 episode (INST-002), and no candidate has survived independent replication. The record remains open to reopening under AT-001 should a future material meet the tightened standard.
Verification Stage: VS-04 after ratified review (stored code VS-05 preserved).
2026-06-29
Reassessed, no change — Collapsed
The claim remains unsatisfied and the pressure state remains COLLAPSED. IN-006 documents that the field did not go quiet after the 2024 null result — a nickelate stabilisation at ambient pressure (Feb 2025), a new 298K high-pressure record (Nov 2025, unreplicated), and a March 2026 field-wide research roadmap all represent real activity — but none meets AT-001's reopening condition: zero resistance, Meissner effect, and specific-heat anomaly, confirmed independently, under the community's tightened standard. The November 2025 result is the closest superficial match to a 'room-temperature' headline since LK-99, and is explicitly logged here so that the record does not appear to have missed it; on examination it fails the same threshold IN-001 through IN-003 already established — high pressure, no independent confirmation, no full evidentiary set. This assessment exists to confirm the COLLAPSED state remains correct under current evidence, not to revise it. The record's status remains CLOSED.
Sourced from: SLAC/Stanford nickelate result via Physics World and ScienceDaily coverage (Feb 2025, reported through 2025–26); La-Sc-H 298K claim via Physics World coverage of an arXiv preprint (Nov 2025) — not independently replicated, and the arXiv preprint itself not directly read; PNAS roadmap referenced via secondary summary (March 2026), primary paper not directly read. Given this record's COLLAPSED/CLOSED status and the high public-interest sensitivity of room-temperature superconductivity claims, primary-source verification of the 298K claim in particular is recommended before this assessment is cited as authoritative.
Verification Stage: VS-04 after ratified review (stored code VS-05 preserved).
Mutation Log
MutationDateFieldPrior valueCurrent value
M-0122026-07-09description_reorderedDESCRIPTION-REORDERED
M-0112026-07-08reference_correctedREFERENCE-CORRECTED
M-0102026-06-29open_question_raisedOQ-RAISED
M-0092026-06-29assessment_issuedAS-001AS-002
M-0082026-06-29instances_loggedINSTANCES-LOGGED
M-0072026-06-18record_id_migratedFR-MF-0005FR-AM-0005
M-0062024-01-15programme_panel_addedPROGRAMME-PANEL-ADDED
M-0052024-01-15null_condition_failedNULL-CONDITION-FAILED
M-0042024-01-15mechanisms_recordedMECHANISMS-RECORDED
M-0032024-01-15assessment_issuedASSESSMENT-ISSUED
M-0022024-01-15instances_loggedINSTANCES-LOGGED
M-0012024-01-15record_createdRECORD-CREATED
Evidence Sources
6 instances on recordShow sources ↓Hide ↑
IN-001Ranga Dias / University of Rochester — carbonaceous sulfur hydride and lutetium hydride claimscontesting
IN-002LK-99 — rapid global replication attempt and failurecontesting
IN-003High-pressure hydride superconductors — confirmed reproducibility below room temperaturepartial
IN-004Community methodological response — reproducibility standards tightenneutral
IN-005Post-LK-99 landscape — no credible room-temperature superconductivity claim survivescontesting
IN-0062025–26 activity — nickelate stabilisation, a new high-pressure record claim, and a field-wide roadmapneutral