← ObservatoryThe RecordFR-AM-0004
PROG-AM
FR-AM-0004

Commercial Fusion Power — Net Electricity at Grid Scale

A commercially viable fusion power plant can generate net electricity at grid scale.

EscalatingVS-03·since 2026-06-29
Verification Matrix
VS-01
Assertion
VS-02
Published
VS-03
Audit
2024-01-15 — present
VS-04
Replication
VS-05
Operation
State reached Current state Not yet reached
State Warrant
Current stateEscalatingVS-03
Why this state?Sourced from: Commonwealth Fusion Systems public statements on SPARC assembly timeline (Q1 2025); General Fusion press materials and Utility Dive coverage of LM26 first-plasma milestone (Feb 2025, reported Sept 2025); U.S. DOE fusion-commercialisation roadmap announcement (Oct 2025). Accessed via secondary reporting, not primary DOE/company technical filings — primary sourcing recommended before treating SPARC's 2026 target date as confirmed rather than stated.
Assessment summaryNo threshold has been crossed since AS-001. Threshold 1 (plant-level net electricity) remains undemonstrated; SPARC's own net-energy target is dated for 2026 and is not yet realised as of this assessment. What has changed is the density of engineering-milestone activity: SPARC assembly beginning, General Fusion's first-plasma result, and a coordinated DOE commercialisation roadmap all occurred within roughly the same window (late 2025), constituting the most concentrated burst of public engineering progress since the 2022 NIF/JET results that originally moved this record into ESCALATING. None of IN-006's events individually changes the assessment — they are pre-threshold engineering progress, the same evidence category as IN-003 — but their concentration is itself worth noting against OQ-001's resolution-criteria question: if SPARC's stated 2026 net-energy target is met, the Observatory will need exactly the governed procedure OQ-001 asks for and does not yet have.
State entered2024-01-15
Last reaffirmed2026-06-29
Stage provenanceRatified VS-03; stored historical code VS-02 preserved.
Record Lineage — Chronological
2024-01-15
Record opened — Escalating
The claim requires three thresholds to be met simultaneously: net electricity at plant level, grid-scale capacity, and commercial viability. None has been demonstrated. The furthest-reached threshold is threshold 1 (net electricity), which has been approached but not achieved at the plant level — NIF achieved Q > 1 at target level, not at facility level. Thresholds 2 and 3 are not yet addressable by current experimental evidence. The pressure state is ESCALATING. The NIF ignition result (INST-002) demonstrates that positive fusion energy gain is achievable in the laboratory, a necessary, though not sufficient, precondition for all three thresholds even though it satisfies none of them directly. Substantial private capital (INST-003) and a public ITER/DEMO roadmap (INST-004) indicate the engineering path is being actively pursued, but threshold 1 (plant-level net electricity) remains undemonstrated, and thresholds 2 and 3 cannot yet be meaningfully assessed given the sequential dependency between them (BN-001).
Verification Stage: VS-03 after ratified review (stored code VS-02 preserved).
2026-06-29
Reassessed, no change — Escalating
No threshold has been crossed since AS-001. Threshold 1 (plant-level net electricity) remains undemonstrated; SPARC's own net-energy target is dated for 2026 and is not yet realised as of this assessment. What has changed is the density of engineering-milestone activity: SPARC assembly beginning, General Fusion's first-plasma result, and a coordinated DOE commercialisation roadmap all occurred within roughly the same window (late 2025), constituting the most concentrated burst of public engineering progress since the 2022 NIF/JET results that originally moved this record into ESCALATING. None of IN-006's events individually changes the assessment — they are pre-threshold engineering progress, the same evidence category as IN-003 — but their concentration is itself worth noting against OQ-001's resolution-criteria question: if SPARC's stated 2026 net-energy target is met, the Observatory will need exactly the governed procedure OQ-001 asks for and does not yet have.
Sourced from: Commonwealth Fusion Systems public statements on SPARC assembly timeline (Q1 2025); General Fusion press materials and Utility Dive coverage of LM26 first-plasma milestone (Feb 2025, reported Sept 2025); U.S. DOE fusion-commercialisation roadmap announcement (Oct 2025). Accessed via secondary reporting, not primary DOE/company technical filings — primary sourcing recommended before treating SPARC's 2026 target date as confirmed rather than stated.
Verification Stage: VS-03 after ratified review (stored code VS-02 preserved).
Mutation Log
MutationDateFieldPrior valueCurrent value
M-0122026-07-09description_reorderedDESCRIPTION-REORDERED
M-0112026-07-08realization_note_addedREN-001
M-0102026-06-29open_question_raisedOQ-RAISED
M-0092026-06-29assessment_issuedAS-001AS-002
M-0082026-06-29instances_loggedINSTANCES-LOGGED
M-0072026-06-18record_id_migratedFR-MF-0004FR-AM-0004
M-0062024-01-15programme_panel_addedPROGRAMME-PANEL-ADDED
M-0052024-01-15null_condition_failedNULL-CONDITION-FAILED
M-0042024-01-15mechanisms_recordedMECHANISMS-RECORDED
M-0032024-01-15assessment_issuedASSESSMENT-ISSUED
M-0022024-01-15instances_loggedINSTANCES-LOGGED
M-0012024-01-15record_createdRECORD-CREATED
Evidence Sources
6 instances on recordShow sources ↓Hide ↑
IN-001JET and ITER-predecessor experiments — Q < 1, physics establishedneutral
IN-002NIF ignition — first fusion Q > 1 (target gain)supportive
IN-003Private fusion industry — Commonwealth Fusion, TAE, Helion, and otherspartial
IN-004ITER construction and DEMO roadmap — public programme trajectoryneutral
IN-005Economic viability analyses — cost projections and comparison with alternativespartial
IN-0062025 construction and demonstration milestones — SPARC, General Fusion, DOE roadmappartial